Half Full, or Half Empty?
In the above video, the Rev. Zach Zehnder weighs in on the results of his survey question concerning women’s “ordination.” He is optimistic about these numbers, and considers them to be a sign of unity. He sees the glass half full.
I look at the same numbers and am quite alarmed at our lack of unity. I see the glass half empty.
According to his numbers:
85.6 % believe only qualified men should be ordained
9.6% believe women should be “ordained”
4.8% are unsure.
As far as the percentages among those aged 70+, we see 74% for male-only ordination, as opposed to 95% for those aged 18-29 - following the general trajectory of the young being more conservative, and the elderly as more liberal.
The breakdown between men and women is as follows: 89.4% for male-only ordination among men as opposed to 77.2% of women - also following the general trajectory of men being more conservative, with women being more liberal (and more influenced by feminism).
Among pastors, 90% supported male-only ordination.
I find these numbers horrifying, and indicative of a problem of catechesis and worldly influence upon the church. It is probably also driven by biblical illiteracy and confessional unfamiliarity as well. Think about it: ten percent of pastors are willing to consider female “ordination.” Now of course, this is a small unscientific sample - but the numbers are what they are. Close to a quarter of all women who took this survey are willing to consider female “ordination” - and slightly more than a quarter of the elderly, to boot.
The reason we in the LCMS don’t ordain “women” is not because it is a preference, a cultural bias, or a belief that women are lesser Christians. It is rather because we confess the clear revelation of the Word of God on this issue, the example of the Word Made Flesh, the example of the apostles, and the universal practice of the church for more than nineteen centuries. Obviously, the testimony of Scripture trumps everything else - but the example of Christ, the apostles, and the church are not to be disregarded. In other words, male-only ordination is a dogma - just as are the doctrines of the Trinity, the divinity of Christ, and the resurrection of our Lord. We have no authority to change dogma. We believe these things dogmatically, because Scripture testifies to them. We can indeed (and must) bind consciences to them. And yes, there are some who say Scripture has been misinterpreted: Unitarians deny the Trinity, Jehovah’s Witnesses deny the divinity of Christ, and some liberal and rationalistic theologians deny the resurrection. They are wrong - as are organizations that claim to be churches - like the ELCA - that purport to “ordain” women. These are all heretical beliefs.
I want to commend Pastor Zehnder for making the point that Scripture confesses male-only ordination, that it isn’t just a preference or a rule that can be bent in the case of an emergency - as the Rev. Tim Ahlman mused that the occasion of an all-female retreat might be such an “emergency” that would grant a woman exceptional permission to say the Words of Institution over bread and wine and distribute what she purports to be a real sacrament. This quip was in response to his lady parishioner who earned an MDiv degree from an online seminary (whose CEO is a lady “pastor”) after being bothered by the fact that a fellow lady could not consecrate the elements. As for Pastor Zehnder, his confession is certainly more clear here than it was when he and his senior pastor fielded this question.
Every LCMS pastor should be able to clearly confess male-only ordination as dogmatic, even as he confesses the Trinity. He should stand on God’s Word and not waffle about interpretation, as if the synod were to vote to allow it, it would then somehow be acceptable - as happened in the now apostate Lutheran [sic] Church [sic] of Australia. A synodical vote to “ordain” women would be as null and void as a vote to deny the Trinity, the divinity of Jesus, or the resurrection.
It seems that this kind of deconstruction of our dogma may be more common in the LCMS than we would like to think.
I would hope that Pastor Zehnder would not be so optimistic if ten percent of pastors, a quarter of women, and a quarter of elderly laymen of both sexes denied other Scriptural dogmas, like the Trinity, the divinity of Jesus, and the resurrection.
So I see the glass as half-empty here.
But that said, there is one bright spot: the younger demographic. That 25% that denies the Scriptures diminishes to 5% among young people. It’s still not good that even one in twenty holds to an unscriptural position, but the trajectory is a great cause of hope. Pastor Zehnder’s data quantifies what many of us know experientially: a lot of our seasoned LCMS members are quite liberal. They are a product of their times. Television and the spirit of the age poisoned them and had their way with them. But the younger people - many of whom I teach on a regular basis - are far more conservative and traditional. They are more likely to believe the Bible, more likely to shut the television off (or at least be more skeptical), and more likely to see the value in reverent, liturgical worship as opposed to entertainment and marketing.
God may well be raising up faithful young people who confess the faith in all of its fullness. It’s too bad that a significant minority of their elders - who are supposed to be wise - have fallen into generational folly. At the same time, we rejoice with the majority of older folks who have not fallen into false doctrine. So in spite of the snapshot being disturbing, the trend is salutary. The picture is not good, but the video is promising.
So I see the glass as half-empty, but it is filling up as the demographics shift. Let us pray that the half-empty glass be filled by God’s grace!