Gottesblog transparent background.png

Gottesblog

A blog of the Evangelical Lutheran Liturgy

Filter by Month
 
We Have Got to Talk About Usury (Part XVI): The Regensburg Dispute of 1587—A Lesson in Courage and Consequences  

Ed: The below account of the Regensburg Dispute made my blood run cold, and the attentive reader will have no great difficulty in seeing the same patterns at work in ecclesial controversies to this day. - SG

In the middle of the sixteenth century, two opposing views were held among Lutherans with respect to interest-taking. Martin Chemnitz adhered to the traditional view, shared by Luther, that all lending at interest for profit is contrary to Holy Scripture. Others, such as Johannes Aepinus, contended that the biblical prohibition against interest applies only to lending to the poor; therefore, they argued, a distinction must be drawn in lending practices, and interest may rightly be charged to the well-to-do, at least in Zinskauf contracts. For Chemnitz, this distinction was without biblical warrant, and those who introduced it had clearly fallen into error (Loci theologici II (1653), 162). Aepinus, conversely, held that those, including Luther, who failed to make this distinction in lending had themselves committed “a pernicious error” (In psalmum XV commentarius (1543), 29). 

Read More
Guest Author Comment
Hymnody and the Spiritual Realm

The Christian faith is a both/and matter. It is neither spiritual to the detriment of the physical (as Gnostics, and as, to a lesser extent, sacramentarian Evangelicals confess), nor is it material to the detriment of the spiritual (as atheists and rationalists confess).

Read More
Larry Beane Comment
"Dignified Worship" Part Two

Here is the official position of the LCMS on Worship and the use of the ordo (the order and constituent parts of the Divine Service), from a resolution from the 2016 LCMS national Convention. Don't ditch the confession and absolution. Don't ditch the creeds. There is no right to rob the people of the ancient creeds which we wholeheartedly confess. Don't rob the people of the three readings of the lectionary. The Augsburg Confession says specifically we retain vestments and the lectionary. Don't mess with the LORD's Supper. There is great freedom to use various settings. Keep the ORDO. We are not evangelicals. We are Lutherans. — Matt Harrison

Read More
Larry Beane Comments
Throwback Thursday: Style vs. Substance

I often hear the argument that musical style is neutral when it comes to appropriateness for worship, and that the reason we in the Gottesdienst Crowd reject “contemporary worship” is simply because we just happen to like the organ and classical music. In other words, if the words pass theological muster, any musical style may be used for the Divine Service, as Scripture doesn’t specify such things, thus making it a matter of adiaphora.

Read More
Larry Beane Comments
Throwback Thursday: Muslim Friendly Worship?

"For an instant even I was appalled - but only for an instant."

Caught between the pincers of the world and the church, I find myself so jaded these days as to rarely find the energy to even shrug my shoulders at what I see going on around me. But, in the case of the following published paper by the chairman of the Missions Department of Concordia University, Portland, the Rev. Dr. Herb Hoefer, who is, of course, an ordained minister of the Lutheran Church - Missouri Synod, I have nothing else to do than to quote Sir Harry Flashman.

Read More
Larry Beane Comments
Keeping a Holy Advent

The beginning of the new year brings with it a great many resolutions, and I hope that the new church year, beginning today, brings with it some worthwhile resolutions on the part of the everyday Christian. I once read somewhere that a new year’s resolution for January 1st is more effective if begun December 1st, and has a much higher rate of success. So, by all means, begin whatever resolutions you have underway in the coming week, most especially those pertaining to the Christian life.

Read More
Stefan Gramenz Comments