Gottesblog transparent background.png

Gottesblog

A blog of the Evangelical Lutheran Liturgy

Filter by Author
Filter by Category
Filter by Month
 

The Freedom to Change Is Not the Freedom to Discard

            Getting your Trinity Audio player ready...

A Response to Rev. Steve Zank on the Lutheran Confessions, Adiaphora, and the Historic Liturgy

The Rev. David V. Miller

Lutheran Church of the Ascension, Atlanta, Georgia

To the Rev. Dr. Steve Zank, Concordia University Irvine

Dear Rev. Zank,

The recent On the Line debate with Rev. Bryan Wolfmueller raises a question that deserves considerably more attention than the familiar assertion that Lutheran congregations are free to employ contemporary forms of worship because ceremonies are adiaphora. Of course, the Lutheran Church confesses Christian liberty. Of course, congregations possess legitimate freedom in ordering external ceremonies. And, of course, Martin Luther himself warned against turning a particular order of service into a law that binds consciences. But there is a considerable difference between acknowledging Christian liberty and using Christian liberty to justify the wholesale abandonment of a theological inheritance.

In listening to the argument for contemporary alternatives, I was particularly troubled by the appeal to the Formula of Concord's Article X and to Luther's own statements concerning the freedom of liturgical forms. These texts deserve to be read in their historical and theological context, not isolated from the very controversies that gave them their meaning. Indeed, there is a danger here of making Luther and the Lutheran Confessions say precisely what they were attempting to prevent: that freedom in ceremonies means freedom to neglect the evangelical purposes those ceremonies serve.

The question is not simply whether a congregation may change its ceremonies. The more important question is whether it should, what it communicates by doing so, and whether the change serves or diminishes the proclamation of the Gospel.

The Lutheran Reformers Reformed the Mass; They Did Not Abandon It

Perhaps the best place to begin is with the Augsburg Confession's unmistakable declaration:

"Our churches are falsely accused of abolishing the Mass. The Mass is held among us and celebrated with the highest reverence. Nearly all the usual ceremonies are also preserved, except that the parts sung in Latin are interspersed here and there with German hymns. These have been added to teach the people. For ceremonies are needed for this reason alone, that the uneducated be taught <what they need to know about Christ>. (Augsburg Confession XXIV.1–3.).

Notice the argument. The reformers are defending themselves against accusations of innovation and abolition. Their response is not that they have discovered a new and better form of Christian worship. It is that they have retained the Mass, preserved nearly all its customary ceremonies, and made certain alterations for the sake of teaching. This is important because the Lutheran Reformation did not arise from a desire to liberate Christians from the historical worship of the Church. It arose from the necessity of restoring the Gospel where human additions and abuses had obscured it.

The reformers believed that the Mass had been corrupted by teachings concerning the sacrificial character of the ceremony, the merits of private Masses, and the application of the Mass for the forgiveness of sins apart from faith in Christ. These were not aesthetic disagreements. They concerned the very heart of justification.

The Augsburg Confession explains:

"Our teachers have warned that these opinions depart from the Holy Scripture and diminish the glory of the passion of Christ” (Augsburg Confession XXIV.24).

And it continues by confessing that Christ's one offering has perfected those who are sanctified (Hebrews 10:10, 14).

The Lutheran reformers therefore did not remove the Mass because they considered its inherited structure unnecessary. They removed abuses because those abuses contradicted the Gospel. This is the distinction that must govern the entire discussion.

The reformers were not throwing away an heirloom because they preferred something more fashionable. They were cleaning the tarnish from an inherited treasure because certain additions had obscured its beauty. They wanted the Church to receive again what generations of Christians had received: the Word of God, the proclamation of Christ, and the gifts of His Holy Supper.

The Apology makes the matter even clearer:

"We do not abolish the Mass, but religiously keep and defend it. Masses are celebrated among us every Lord’s Day and on the other festivals. The Sacrament is offered to those who wish to use it, after they have been examined and absolved. And the usual public ceremonies are observed, the series of lessons, of prayers, vestments, and other such things” (Apology of the Augsburg Confession XXIV.1).

This is a remarkable description. Scripture readings, prayers, vestments, and the regular administration of the Sacrament are not treated as embarrassing remnants of a bygone age. They are described as the ordinary public ceremonies of the evangelical Church. The reformers were not seeking to replace the historic Mass with a religious gathering better suited to the preferences of the contemporary congregation. They were seeking to restore the evangelical substance of the Mass.

If we are going to invoke Luther's freedom to reform worship, we must also remember what he actually reformed worship for.

Luther's Christian Liberty Was Not a License for Liturgical Individualism

One of the most frequently invoked passages in this discussion comes from Luther's preface to The German Mass and Order of Service (1526).

Luther writes:

“In the first place, I would kindly and for God’s sake request all those who see this order of service or desire to follow it: Do not make it a rigid law to bind or entangle anyone’s conscience, but use it in Christian liberty as long, when, where, and how you find it to be practical and useful. For this is being published not as though we meant to lord it over anyone else, or to legislate for him, but because of the widespread demand for German masses and services and the general dissatisfaction and offense that has been caused by the great variety of new masses, for everyone makes his own order of service. Some have the best intentions, but others have no more than an itch to produce something novel so that they might shine before men as leading lights, rather than being ordinary teachers” (The German Mass and Order of Service (1526), Preface).

There is an important observation here that deserves attention. Luther was already concerned about people constructing their own services. He recognized that Christian liberty could become an excuse for novelty, personal preference, and ecclesiastical self- importance.

He continues:

"[Such is] always the case with Christian liberty: very few use it for the glory of God and the good of the neighbor; most use it for their own advantage and pleasure. But while the exercise of this freedom is up to everyone’s conscience and must not be cramped or forbidden, nevertheless, we must make sure that freedom shall be and remain a servant of love and of our fellow-man.” (The German Mass, Preface).

And then comes the sentence that should govern every discussion of liturgical freedom:

"Where the people are perplexed and offended by these differences in liturgical usage, however, we are certainly bound to forego our freedom and seek, if possible, to better rather than to offend them by what we do or leave undone” (The German Mass, Preface).

This is hardly an endorsement of endless liturgical experimentation. Luther is not saying that because Christians are free to change ceremonies, they should feel equally free to discard the inherited worship of the Church. He is warning that freedom can become selfishness, that novelty can become vanity, and that the exercise of liberty must be governed by love for the neighbor.

The context matters enormously. Luther was addressing the practical establishment of a German-language order of service in a period when various congregations were producing competing liturgical arrangements. He wanted a usable order, but he did not want his own order imposed as a new law. He was attempting to prevent both legalism and liturgical chaos.

In fact, Luther's German Mass retained the historic structure of the Mass. The Introit, Kyrie, Epistle, Gospel, Creed, sermon, Lord's Prayer, Words of Institution, Sanctus, distribution, Agnus Dei, and benediction remained part of the service, whether translated, adapted, or given new musical settings. He did not use Christian liberty to dispense with the inheritance. He used Christian liberty to make that inheritance accessible to the German- speaking congregation. There is a world of difference between those two things. One might say that Luther gave the Church freedom to tend the garden, not permission to pave it over.

The Apology Explains Why Ceremonies Matter: They Teach Scripture

Perhaps the most overlooked passage in this entire debate is found in the Apology of the Augsburg Confession.

Melanchthon writes:

"However, ceremonies should be celebrated to teach people Scripture, that those admonished by the Word may conceive faith and godly fear, and may also pray. (This is the intent of ceremonies.) So, we keep the Latin language to aid those who are learning and understand Latin. We mix with it German hymns so that the people also may have something to learn, and by which faith and godly fear may be produced” (Apology of the Augsburg Confession XXIV.3).

Read that again. Ceremonies teach Scripture. They admonish through the Word. They call forth faith and reverence. They provide comfort. They teach the congregation to pray. This is not an incidental observation. It is a theological explanation of why the reformers retained the inherited liturgy. The liturgy is not merely an arrangement of external activities

surrounding the supposedly more important portions of worship. Its words and ceremonies serve the proclamation and teaching of the Gospel.

Consider the fivefold Ordinary: the Kyrie, Gloria in Excelsis, Creed, Sanctus, and Agnus Dei. These are not arbitrary musical interludes. They place the biblical confession of sin, the incarnation of Christ, the faith of the Church, the holiness of God, and the saving work of the Lamb of God upon the lips of the congregation. The Scripture readings proclaim God's Word. The sermon expounds that Word. The Creed confesses the faith. The Sanctus joins the congregation to the heavenly worship of Isaiah 6. The Agnus Dei confesses the Christ who takes away the sin of the world. The Words of Institution deliver Christ's testament, and the congregation receives His body and blood.

We should be careful not to claim that every historical rubric or every individual element of the Ordinary is a divine commandment. The Formula of Concord does not permit that confusion. But neither should we confuse the freedom to alter external forms with indifference toward the biblical content those forms carry.

The Word of God is not adiaphora. The Gospel is not adiaphora. Baptism and the Lord's Supper are not adiaphora. The Church's duty to preach, teach, and administer Christ's gifts is not adiaphora. And a congregation should not be indifferent to the forms that have faithfully served these purposes for generations. The distinction is between the freedom to arrange the Church's worship and the responsibility to preserve the evangelical substance of that worship. That distinction is thoroughly Lutheran.

The Formula of Concord Was Not Written to Justify Liturgical Indifference

Now we arrive at the Formula of Concord, Article X, and perhaps the most consequential historical misunderstanding in this debate. The article is frequently invoked as though it were a general declaration that congregations may change their worship however they please. But the historical circumstances that produced Article X reveal a much more serious concern.

The Formula of Concord explains the controversy:

"Some ceremonies and Church practices are neither commanded nor forbidden in God’s Word, but are introduced into the Church with good intention, for the sake of good order and proper custom, or otherwise to maintain Christian discipline. A dispute has arisen among some theologians of the Augsburg Confession about these practices” (Formula of Concord, Solid Declaration X.1).

The controversy did not arise because some congregations wanted contemporary music while others preferred traditional hymnody. It arose in the aftermath of the Schmalkaldic

War, when the Lutheran territories had been defeated by Emperor Charles V. In 1548, the emperor imposed the Augsburg Interim, requiring substantial restoration of Roman Catholic practices. Philip Melanchthon and other Wittenberg theologians subsequently developed the Leipzig Interim, which sought to preserve certain evangelical teachings while making concessions concerning ceremonies. The question was whether Lutherans could accept the restoration of ceremonies that were adiaphora in themselves when those ceremonies were being demanded by opponents of the evangelical confession.

The opposing theologians, particularly Matthias Flacius and his associates, insisted that such concessions could not be made when the ceremonies were being used to obscure the Gospel and gradually reintroduce false doctrine. This is the historical setting of Article X.

The Formula identifies the two positions:

"One side holds that even during persecution and in matter of confession, when the enemies of the Gospel are not in agreement with us in doctrine, some ceremonies (that are adiaphora in themselves, and are neither commanded nor forbidden by God) may be reestablished in compliance with the adversaries’ pressure and demand without damage to our conscience. So in such adiaphora (or matters of indifference), we may compromise with our adversaries” (Formula of Concord, Solid Declaration X.2).

The opposing position was that such concessions were impermissible when they would suppress the pure doctrine of the Gospel. The Formula ultimately sides with the latter position.

It declares:

"Under the title and excuse of outward adiaphora, things are proposed that are in principle contrary to God’s Word, although painted another color. These ceremonies are not to be regarded as adiaphora, in which one is free to do as he wants. They must be avoided as things prohibited by God. In a similar way in such a situation ceremonies should be regarded as genuine free adiaphora, or matters of indifference. This is because they make a show or pretend that our religion and that of the papists are not far apart in order to avoid persecution, or they pretend that the papist’s ceremonies are not at least highly offensive to us. When ceremonies are not at least highly offensive to us. When ceremonies are intended for this purpose, and are required and received (as though through them contrary religions are reconciled and became one body), we cannot regard them as adiaphora.” (Formula of Concord, Solid Declaration X.5).

It further states:

"Likewise, when there are useless, foolish displays that are not profitable for good order, Christian discipline, or evangelical practice in the Church, these also are not genuine adiaphora, or matters of indifference” (Formula of Concord, Solid Declaration X.7).

And, of particular importance:

"We also believe, teach, and confess that at a time of confession, when the enemies of God’s Word want to suppress the pure doctrine of the Holy Gospel, God’s entire church, indeed, every single Christian, but especially the ministers of the Word, as the directors of the community of God <God’s church>, is bound by God’s Word to confess the doctrine freely and openly. They are bound to confess every aspect of <pure> religion, not only in words, but also in works and actions” (Formula of Concord, Solid Declaration X.10).

The article concludes that in such circumstances Christians must not yield to their adversaries, even in matters that are genuinely adiaphora, when yielding would harm the confession of the Gospel. This is not a minor qualification. It is the very reason the article exists. The Formula does not teach that ceremonies are unchangeable. It teaches that Christian liberty cannot be manipulated to undermine the Gospel.

It is worth asking, therefore: if the Formula was written to oppose the use of ceremonial freedom as a means of concealing or compromising the evangelical confession, why should we employ it to justify a wholesale movement away from the Church's inherited evangelical forms? That is not merely an ironic application. It risks reversing the historical purpose of the article.

The Confessional Obligation to Confess Through Our Practice

There is an especially important principle in Article X that deserves to be applied to our present circumstances. The Formula says that Christians are sometimes bound to confess the truth not only in words but also in works and deeds. That principle has consequences for contemporary Lutheran worship.

Imagine a congregation in which the historic liturgy is dismissed as outdated, unnecessary, or interchangeable with whatever happens to be popular in contemporary Christian culture. Imagine that its doctrinally rich hymnody is replaced with songs that communicate little beyond generalized expressions of religious affection. Imagine that the congregation is told that the difference does not matter because both approaches are technically permissible. At that point, the question is no longer merely whether the congregation has permission to change an external ceremony. The question is what the change communicates about the Church's confession.

If Christians around us insist that the historic liturgy is disposable, that doctrinally rich Lutheran hymnody is no better than the latest popular Christian recording, and that the congregation loses nothing by abandoning its inherited forms, then we should be careful not to confuse silence with neutrality.

I would not argue that every contemporary musical setting or alternative order of service is inherently unfaithful. Nor does the Formula require us to manufacture a confessional crisis whenever a congregation changes a hymn or a ceremony. But when the historic liturgy is systematically treated as an obstacle to the Gospel, and its replacement is defended on the grounds that doctrinal substance and theological formation are of little consequence, the issue deserves to be confronted.

The Formula's principle is that we cannot permit the confession of the Gospel to be obscured under the pretext of Christian liberty. That principle should make us think very carefully before surrendering the Church's evangelical inheritance merely to demonstrate our flexibility.

The Hymnal Is Not a Musical Preference; It Is a Treasury of Doctrine

The same argument applies to Lutheran hymnody. One of the great achievements of the Lutheran Reformation was its recovery of congregational singing as a means of teaching and confessing the faith. Luther understood that the people of God needed more than songs that expressed religious enthusiasm. They needed songs that taught them what God had done for them in Christ. This is why the Apology specifically identifies German hymns as instruments through which the people learn and faith and reverence are called forth.

Consider three examples.

"Dear Christians, One and All, Rejoice" teaches the sinner's bondage under sin, the inability of human works to justify, the gracious intervention of God, the incarnation of Christ, His atoning death, and the gift of righteousness received through faith.

"Salvation unto Us Has Come" places the relationship between Law and Gospel, justification, faith, and good works into the congregation's mouth with extraordinary theological precision.

"Christ Jesus Lay in Death's Strong Bands" proclaims the resurrection, the defeat of death, the atoning sacrifice of Christ, and the victory of the risen Lord.

These are not simply old songs that happen to be familiar to Lutherans. They are theological instruction set to music. They form the Christian mind. They give the congregation a vocabulary for confessing the faith. They teach the difference between Law and Gospel and direct the conscience away from its own achievements toward Christ.

And here is the problem with treating all congregational music as interchangeable: not all songs teach the same things. A song may be emotionally moving, musically excellent, and entirely appropriate in a particular devotional setting without being an adequate substitute for a hymn that teaches the full biblical doctrine of sin, grace, justification, the cross, and the Sacraments. The question is not whether contemporary Christian music can ever be doctrinally sound. Certainly it can. The question is whether it is doing the same catechetical work as the great hymns of the Lutheran tradition.

We should not assume that it is. A congregation that regularly sings the great Lutheran chorales is being catechized week after week. It is learning the faith not merely through the pastor's sermon but through its own confession. When that hymnody disappears, something more substantial than a musical preference has been lost. The Church has lost a treasury of theological instruction. And that loss has consequences for the congregation's understanding of the Gospel.

The Liturgy Is the Gospel Given, Confessed, and Received

There is one final point that should not be overlooked. The liturgy is not simply a collection of human words about God. Properly understood, it is saturated with the Word of God. Its Scripture readings, biblical canticles, prayers, creedal confessions, hymns, and sacramental words place God's promises before His people. The congregation hears the Word, confesses the Word, sings the Word, and receives Christ's gifts.

Romans 10:17 tells us that faith comes through hearing the Word of Christ. This is why the Lutheran concern for the liturgy is not ultimately an aesthetic concern. It is a concern for the proclamation and delivery of the Gospel through the means God has appointed. The liturgy is not powerful because it is old, elaborate, or ceremonially impressive. Its power is in the Word of God that it proclaims and the Sacraments that Christ instituted. And that is precisely why we should be reluctant to discard it.

The historic liturgy gives the congregation a remarkably rich and consistent diet of Scripture. It does not depend upon the weekly ingenuity of a worship leader or the changing tastes of a particular generation. It gives the people the same biblical confession Sunday after Sunday. It is a form of worship that has been tested, received, and refined across generations. We do not need to reinvent the Church's confession every Sunday. We need to receive it, believe it, confess it, and pass it along. The liturgy is not a museum piece. It is a living inheritance.

Let the Confessions Interpret the Confessions

Rev. Zank, I would suggest that the greatest danger in this discussion is not that some Lutheran congregations might employ a different order of service. It is that we might

become so accustomed to appealing to Christian liberty that we forget the evangelical purpose for which that liberty exists.

The Formula of Concord does not stand alone. Neither does Luther's preface to the German Mass. Neither does the Augsburg Confession's discussion of ceremonies. These documents belong together. The Augsburg Confession and its Apology explain why the Mass was retained, why its ceremonies were preserved, why congregational singing was encouraged, and why the people needed to be taught through the Word. Luther explains that freedom must serve the neighbor and must not become an excuse for personal novelty. The Formula of Concord explains that freedom must never be employed to compromise the confession of the Gospel. Read together, these sources do not produce an argument for liturgical indifference. They produce a compelling argument for preserving and employing the Church's inherited forms in service of the Gospel.

There is a principle familiar to every Lutheran theologian: let Scripture interpret Scripture. I would propose that we apply a similar principle to our confessional documents: let the Confessions interpret the Confessions. Do not isolate Luther's statement about freedom from his actual liturgical reforms. Do not isolate Formula of Concord X.9 from X.5, X.7, and X.10. Do not invoke the freedom to alter ceremonies while ignoring the Augsburg Confession's insistence that ceremonies teach Christ and the Apology's insistence that they teach Scripture. And do not forget that the reformers themselves defended the historic Mass against accusations that they had abandoned it.

The Lutheran inheritance is not an obstacle to the Gospel. It is one of the great gifts through which the Gospel has been proclaimed, taught, sung, and received. We have inherited a treasure. We should not treat it as though it were a burden. The Church does not need to choose between Christian liberty and liturgical faithfulness. It needs to understand that Christian liberty exists to serve the Gospel and the neighbor.

Let us therefore stop cherry-picking the Confessions to justify our preferred worship practices. Let us read them as a whole, in their historical context, and allow their theology to govern our decisions. Let us retain the Mass, celebrate it reverently, offer the Sacrament regularly, teach the people through the rich ceremonies of the Church, and preserve the doctrinally substantial hymnody that has formed generations of Lutheran Christians.

We are not called to invent a new inheritance for every generation. We are called to be faithful stewards of the one we have received. And that inheritance has a name: the Gospel of Jesus Christ, crucified and risen for sinners, delivered through His Word and Sacraments.

That is what the Lutheran Reformation fought to preserve. That is what our Confessions teach. And that is what our worship should continue to confess.

Respectfully,

A fellow Lutheran who believes our inheritance is worth keeping.

Guest AuthorComment