Gottesblog transparent background.png

Gottesblog

A blog of the Evangelical Lutheran Liturgy

Filter by Author
Filter by Category
Filter by Month
 
The Lutheran Sources of the Common Service (Part 1)

The object of these pages is to exhibit the Lutheran sources of the Common Service. The libraries at Philadelphia and Gettysburg can furnish much additional matter, for I am compelled to depend on my own meagre collection and notes; but they will only confirm and reinforce my positions. Let me ask those who have an interest in the subject to patiently read a few dry pages, in order that they may see how completely the Common Service sets forth “the common consent of the pure Lutheran Liturgies of the Sixteenth Century, and when there is not entire agreement among them, the consent of the largest number of those of greatest weight."

Read More
Stefan GramenzComment
Throwback Thursday: Of "Father" and "Mass"

Since its inception Gottesdienst has included the title Father for clergymen and the term Mass for, well, for the Mass, as part of its style guide. This, along with the chasubles, chanting, and genuflecting will sometimes provoke the charge of "too Catholic" or "weirdos" or even things less complimentary.

Read More
Heath CurtisComment
The Common Service and Contemporary Worship: An Historical Review

Many of our readers either watched or heard about the highly advertised debate on contemporary worship between Rev. Bryan Wolfmueller and Rev. Stephen Zank, which was recently recorded at Luther Classical College and premiered on the On the Line podcast on Monday. There is much that has been said on the debate, and much more that could still be said, but I will confine myself to one set of repeated assertions from Rev. Stephen Zank, which generally equated the communion liturgy of The Common Service of 1888 (as found on p. 15 of The Lutheran Hymnal or in Lutheran Service Book, Setting Three) and its divergence from the German communion liturgy of the LCMS’ German Agenda with the various innovations and changes being introduced today under the name of “contemporary worship.” His argument on this front was, broadly, that the Lutheran Church—Missouri Synod had adopted a relatively novel form of worship with the introduction of the Common Service in the beginning of the twentieth century, an introduction that marked a break with its received German-language tradition, and that refusing to adopt other relatively novel forms or modifications of the existing service today is itself ahistorical and untraditional, as we had previously been much more tolerant of divergences from the received liturgical forms.

Read More
Stefan Gramenz Comments
The Organ Refuses to be Silenced

The organ has been at the center of our Lutheran church music for five centuries. The “king of instruments” had already established itself in the west centuries before Luther and the reformers. And since one of the objectives of the Reformation was to restore music and congregational singing to the worship life of Christians, it makes perfect sense that the organ would become so endearing and enduring to our Lutheran identity.

Read More
Larry Beane Comments
Render to Caesar

Instead of understanding that God rules all things and entrusts a certain degree of authority to Caesar, many live as though Caesar rules all and permits the church to operate in a small corner of society.

Read More
Evan ScammanComment
A Debate on the Liturgy

Tonight, Monday, November 9, 2026, 7 pm Central time, the above pre-recorded debate will go live. The Thesis is: “Resolved: For the sake of the clarity of the Gospel, Lutheran congregations should preserve the historic orders of the Divine Service rather than adopt contemporary alternative forms, even when those alternatives are confessionally sound.” The Rev. Bryan Wolfmueller argues in the affirmative, and the Rev. Dr. Steve Zank argues in the negative.

When it premiers live, you will have the opportunity to comment in real time.

Read More
Larry Beane Comments
Football Stadium Teleology

Why do football stadiums basically look the same? There are certainly differences in size, whether or not they have a dome, and the external aesthetics of the building. They are individually known by different names. But that said, you can drive by a football stadium - whether at the local high school campus, the university, or in a big city that has an NFL presence - and you will know that this is a stadium…

Read More
Larry Beane Comments
Consecration of an Acolyte

I’ve often heard the service of the acolyte being downplayed as “just lighting candles.” If that’s the case, why have them at all? And since we now have electricity, why have candles at all? For anyone in the congregation can flip the switch. Such denigration of acolyte service is unfortunate and ill-advised.

Read More
Larry Beane Comments
What Kind of Love?

The Hebrew chesed is normally translated as “mercy,” which doesn’t quite do it justice, because the term contains also elements of eager zeal and desire, that is, fierceness; and it is commonly used in the imprecatory Psalms.

Read More
Burnell Eckardt Comments
The Emperor's New Clothes, Part Deux (LCMS Redux)

In the great city where he lived, life was always gay. Every day many strangers came to town, and among them one day came two swindlers. They let it be known they were weavers, and they said they could weave the most magnificent fabrics imaginable. Not only were their colors and patterns uncommonly fine, but clothes made of this cloth had a wonderful way of becoming invisible to anyone who was unfit for his office, or who was unusually stupid.

Read More
Larry Beane Comment
The Rhetoric of Fear

I’m against changing our pastoral formation paradigm not because I’m afraid of something. I just believe that pastoral formation is important, and like training lawyers, soldiers, doctors, and pilots, is not only about the acquisition of information, but of being formed into a way of life.

Read More
Larry Beane Comments
There's an App for That: Lutheran Missal and Breviary app on iOS and Android

For the last few years, we’ve been testing The Lutheran Missal materials with a limited field testing audience, first the temporal lectionary, then the sanctuary lectionary, then the gradual texts, after that the collects, and now the complends (post-communions) and super populums (for weekdays in Lent).

We’re happy to announce that now anyone can access the mass texts for every day of the year in the new app for The Lutheran Missal, available for iOS and Android.

Read More
Stefan Gramenz Comments
Fr. Gunnar Rosendal on the Office (Part 4) - Bishop and Priest

Is a Bishop just a priest, or is a priest a Bishop?

If a Bishop has no other ability than the priest, then he is simply a priest. He has a higher dignity, but so does a pröst. [trans. note: This term could be used for a prior, the dean of a region under a bishop, or one who is a pastor in his own parish as opposed to being under a kyrkoherde. In any of these senses it is an honor given to a priest.] A monsignor and a cardinal, an archpriest and an abbot, these are all higher 23 dignities of the clerical estate, but all these high prelates are only priests. And there is a significant group of theologians, who cannot be denied the epithet catholic, in the present day, who believe that the Bishop is a priest.

Read More
Stefan Gramenz Comment